Gilmore, Graham, and Jindal just don’t sound Presidential. Graham in particular is a joke. He is just insulting people, not giving any substantive answers.
Santorum is just “meh”.
Pataki just seemed to fade into the background.
Kudos to Perry for showing up. He did much better than 4 years ago, but that is a really low bar.
Carly Fiorina is impressive. Direct, substantive responses. She did a great job of packaging a lot of good information into clear, concise answers. She is the only candidate from this debate who deserves to move up to the varsity.